MACOMB -- David Sedaris, billed as “one of America’s preeminent humor writers,” winner of many awards, including Time magazine’s “Humorist of the Year in 2001,“ appeared in a 90-minute gig at Western Illinois University on Oct. 17.
But he wasn’t very funny.
As a comic performer, Sedaris rates about a C minus on the A to F scale.
Fans of National Public Radio know his distinctive voice and side splitting radio essays, especially the ones that made him famous, such as “SantaLand Diaries” on NPR’s Morning Edition.
But alas -- he’s no stand up comic, as his show at WIU proved.
He spent almost an hour reading from previously published essays in the New Yorker and other places. They were only mildly amusing and often boring.
For humor they rely too heavily on shock -- four letter words, comments about homosexuality (“which one’s the man?” -- Sedaris is openly gay) and slightly comic situations such as buying drugs from hillbillies in a trailer who call their TV remote “nigger,” because “it works for free.”
Not really funny, just kind of weird.
At that point in the show, a few older people in the audience headed for the door.
The show got better when Sedaris became slightly more spontaneous by reading from the diary he says he keeps daily.
Here‘s a likely entry from his trip to downstate Illinois: to reach Macomb he flew to Peoria, was picked up (he doesn’t drive, he said) and stopped for lunch at the Hog Trough in Hanna City. Where the pie was good, he said.
When question time finally arrived, someone asked him about writing, and he said he revises a piece at least seven times before showing it to an editor. He tries out new material on audiences, he said. “The first draft is joyous, the second one is math.”
Asked why he has quit smoking, since he once famously said he moved to France so he could smoke, he said he quit because “all the decent hotels went no smoking.“
Airline travel, also, has become too difficult for a smoker, he said. “I hate being this way, but I say ‘OK, you won,’ “ he proclaimed to the current non-smoking consensus.
Then in one of his few funny lines, which may have been spontaneous, he said: “Before quitting I recruited a 17-year-old girl to take my place. I don’t want to leave a hole in the smoking world.”
Sedaris said nothing remotely political. He’s no Jon Stewart, and no Garrison Keillor either.
Keillor’s humor always has an edge that, oddly, Sedaris lacks. Keillor also makes audiences laugh heartily at the human condition without using four letter words or insulting situations. He finds comedy and satire in the ordinary. What would Keillor have done with the Hog Trough material?
In short Sedaris was disappointing as a performer. He’s a writer whose work doesn’t translate into the kind of comic performance that audiences expect.
A book reading at Barnes & Noble? Perhaps. On a stage before an audience? No.
Sigh.
--Elaine Hopkins
COMMENTS:
I wasn’t at the David Sedaris event in Macomb, but I have seen him live twice – once in Springfield and once in Bloomington. I think he is hilarious and probably one of my favorite modern writers.
Sedaris’ writing is wonderful. From word choice to mellifluous turns of phrase, he captures the comedic and the insightful in nearly everything he does. I can pick up one of his essays I have read a dozen times and still find myself laughing out loud. I don’t find his humor to be based on shock value. He is straightforward and honest, and funny to the core.
As for his live readings, I find his unique voice and fabulous delivery make his readings a lot of fun. I have had the pleasure of meeting him, and he is delightful.
Again, I wasn’t in Macomb, and perhaps he had a bad night. But I would hope that your readers that are not familiar with his work would check out one his books and decide for themselves, and not just rely on your review. Or perhaps listen to one of his books on tape.
Also, having lived in Macomb for four years, I would advise anyone to not lend credence to the fact that some “older people headed for the door.” The senior citizen crowd in Macomb has walked out on world class artists playing music of Igor Stravinsky, poetry readings by Billy Collins, and art exhibits from people who have had solo shows at MOMA. I think in that regard, Mr. Sedaris should be happy to be included in that company.
Feel free to post this in your comments section.
Jonathan Ahl
News Director
WCBU - Peoria, IL
[email protected]
309-677-2773
The Chicago Tribune has an interesting interview with Sedaris in its Oct. 19 Tempo section.