PEORIA, IL -- The public comments at the Feb. 24 meeting of the Peoria School District 150 board focused on students.
Activist Terry Knapp continued his protest against the Quest public charter school by saying that a Quest high school student who recently won an award could compete with the best Peoria high school students, an odd comment to use in attacking Quest.
He focused on the Quest lawyer who recently said the Quest students couldn't compete. But as decades of research shows, school performance depends on family background, with middle class students doing well, and poor students not doing well unless they are highly intelligent.
Here is a recording of the comments.
Activist Sharon Crews talked about English curriculum, and what should be taught. Her fascinating remarks are printed below.
-- Elaine Hopkins
I believe there is concern about disparities that exist in 150 schools. I am concerned about disparities that might exist between the English curriculum in our schools and the curriculum in suburban and private schools.
Also, I am concerned that our teachers might be encouraged not to require much homework. As long as classic literature is taught in suburban and private middle and high schools, I believe our students should be exposed to the same literature to prepare them in case they decide to go to college where they must compete with these better prepared students. Personally, I do not know how this literature can be taught without homework.
Each English teacher has his or her own idea as to how to teach literature. Over the years, I developed my methods which I am sharing with you tonight. I started every poem, short story, or novel, etc., with a vocabulary assignment, using unfamiliar words from sentences taken directly from the literature. The students were asked to copy the sentence, replacing the underlined vocabulary word with its definition.
Hopefully, when reading the literature, students would recognize the sentences and vocabulary words used in the assignment and subsequently discussed.
I prepared closure assignments, writing a summary of the literary work and then putting a blank in place of important words, names, or phrases, etc., so that when the assignment was complete, the student had a summary of the literary work.
Then I provided a study guide with questions to use for classroom discussions and sometimes for assignments. I used the information required in homework and covered in discussions to write quizzes and tests.
I hope administrators no longer harass teachers about using too much paper or accuse them of using paper for busy work. Money spent on copy paper and toner for teacher-created assignments is money better spent than the thousands of dollars spent on the miracle-cure programs, many of which are stashed away in drawers.
Teachers, who communicate with students every day, are much more qualified to know what kind of assignments are most effective with their own students than are the creators of computer programs.
In the early 1970’s, Chet Dugger, the curriculum director, convinced Harry Whitaker to say “yes” to the Manual English teachers’ request to plan mini-courses of their choice as long as the literature chosen was taken from our curriculum guide. I chose to develop a course called “Monster Literature,” featuring Beowulf and Frankenstein.
I had seen the movie “Camelot” and read the book The Once and Future King, so I requested buying copies of the book for a course about the legend of King Arthur.
Students were allowed to sign up for the courses of their choice. Recently, at the board meeting held at the Romaine Arts Center, a former student from the 70s stopped to say “Hi” and to tell me that he remembers the King Arthur course as his favorite high school English course.
Shortly after, another student from the 70s reported on Facebook that Beowulf in the Monster course was his favorite—I was happy to hear these unsolicited compliments in that 45 years is a long time to remember a course. I think the mini courses were offered only to juniors and seniors for a year.
When Jeff Dutro joined the Manual faculty, he asked for and received permission to teach a course using poetry about Vietnam and relating what he learned on his graduation gift trip to Vietnam.
Students enjoyed these courses with the personal touch. I probably should add that a former student just joined my Facebook page and told me that she loved me but she hated Macbeth. So far, students who hated me have not come on Facebook to inform me.
I loved teaching grammar, so I created many assignments. To give students something to do while I took roll and passed out make-up, I created daily sentences with as many errors to correct as I could conjure up.
Please be sure that the district’s students are college-ready. District150 cheated me by giving me business English instead of senior English with no exposure to British literature. Secretaries should, also, be well-read.- 30 -